AI transformation · Leadership · Pope Leo XIV · Human dignity

The Pope just drew a line between art and algorithms. Leaders should read it too.

On October 2, Pope Leo XIV received a group of artists and curators in the Consistory Hall at the Vatican, for a meeting organized by the Dicastery for Culture and Education. Honestly, I thought it would be one of those talks that stays inside the art world. It doesn't. I read it twice, and the second time I was reading as an operator, as someone who goes into companies to help them bring AI into the way they work.

You can read the full address here: Address of Pope Leo XIV to artists and curators, October 2, 2026. It's short. I really recommend it.

What caught me first was the part about search engines. He says we live surrounded by tools that give us thousands of instant answers, and no matter how powerful they are, they only return what already exists and tend to give us what we already want. And he says the big danger today is homogenization, everything starting to look and sound the same, plus so much noise that nobody can actually listen anymore.

I read that and thought about every marketing team I've worked with in the last two years.

Because that's exactly the trap. You open the tool, you ask for a campaign, a post, a positioning statement, and what comes back is the average of everything that already exists. It's clean, it's fast, it's fine. And it looks a lot like what your competitor got from the same tool yesterday. Then everybody is surprised that nobody remembers the brand.

He contrasts that with art, which he describes as a different kind of search engine, one that works by asking and digging instead of indexing. Art keeps looking for the thread that connects things. I think good strategy works like that too. Good brand work too. Good leadership, honestly.

Then comes the line I keep repeating to everyone this week. Talking about AI, he says there's a difference between human art and what a machine generates from statistical calculation over millions of images other people made, and that this difference is ontological before it's aesthetic. It's about what the thing is, way before how it looks. And then, quoting his own encyclical Magnifica Humanitas, he says that "algorithms lack the spark of the human."

I want to be careful here, because I'm a big fan of AI. I use it every day, I shipped an app with it, I help companies adopt it. Nothing in this talk tells me to stop. He's not asking anyone to throw the tools away. What he does is call for an alliance to safeguard what is human. And I think that alliance needs to exist inside companies too, and in museums and churches as well.

So what does that look like for a leader on a Monday morning?

For me it starts with being honest about which part of the work is the spark. In every company there's a part of the job that is repetitive, that nobody misses when it's gone. Reconciling spreadsheets, formatting reports, looking for the same information in five different places. Give that to the machine, please, and give people their hours back. But there's another part that is the reason the company exists. The way your best salesperson reads a room. The way your designer sees something nobody asked for. The way your customer service person knows when someone on the phone is having a terrible day. That's the spark. If your AI plan treats that part as one more process to optimize, you'll get efficient and forgettable at the same time.

The second thing is to stop measuring creative work only by volume. AI made it very cheap to produce more. More posts, more emails, more variations. And honestly the noise he describes is partly us, marketers, filling every channel because we can. I'd rather have one campaign someone actually stops to look at than fifty that blend into the feed.

The third thing is more personal. He thanks the artists for walking alongside the Church, and he tells them they are needed. I loved that. The people on our teams who carry that spark need to hear the same thing from us, especially now. A lot of them are scared. When you bring AI into their work, tell them clearly which part of their work you're protecting and why. Say it out loud, because people won't assume it.

I spent years at Hallow, a Catholic prayer app, and our rule was simple: only real testimonials, from real people. Nothing fabricated, even when it would have been easy. Reading this talk I felt that same principle from a different angle. There are things a company can automate, and there are things a company has to keep human if it wants to keep its soul.

Read the talk. Share it with your team. And maybe ask in your next meeting: what's the spark in what we do here, and are we protecting it?

A note when there’s something worth sharing.

New articles, things I’m building and the occasional lesson from the work. I’ll write when I have something worth sending.